Bea Arthur Fought the Same Battle Twice, a Decade Apart

TLDR: Bea Arthur walked away from two hit shows for almost the exact same reason. Both times, she left on her own terms rather than let a writers’ room define her character for her, and even her own last name came from a marriage that barely lasted three years.

---

Bea Arthur was born Bernice Frankel on May 13, 1922, in Brooklyn, to Jewish immigrant parents, Rebecca from Austria and Philip from Poland. She was the middle of three sisters, and by age 12 she was already the tallest girl in her school, a height that would later become as much a part of her stage presence as her deep, deadpan voice.

Her father’s business struggled during the Great Depression, and in 1933 the family relocated to Cambridge, Maryland, where her parents opened a women’s clothing store. There were few other Jewish families in town, and Arthur later described herself as a “painfully shy” child who felt like a genuine misfit.

A Blood Disorder Sent Her Away to Boarding School

At 16, Arthur developed coagulopathy, a serious condition in which her blood wouldn’t clot properly. Concerned for her safety, her parents sent her to Linden Hall, an all-girls boarding school in Lititz, Pennsylvania, where she graduated in 1941.

She studied for two years at Blackstone College for Girls before enrolling at the Franklin Institute of Science and Arts, where she trained as a medical laboratory technician, a fact almost nobody associates with the actress who’d later win two Emmys for comedy.

Her Own Last Name Came From a Marriage That Barely Lasted

Bernice Frankel served as a Staff Sergeant in the United States Marine Corps Women’s Reserve during World War II, working as a typist and truck driver from 1943 until her honorable discharge in September 1944, one of the first women in active-duty Marine service.

In 1944, she also married writer Robert Alan Aurthur, a marriage that ended in divorce by 1947.

She kept a version of his name anyway, and “Bernice Frankel” became “Bea Arthur” around the same time the marriage ended. Her stage career had already started taking shape through an off-Broadway group connected to the Cherry Lane Theater, studying alongside teachers Erwin Piscator and, briefly, a classmate named Tennessee Williams.

She Built a Real Broadway Career Before Television Ever Noticed Her

In 1950, Arthur married director Gene Saks, a marriage that lasted 28 years and produced two sons, Matthew and Daniel, before ending in divorce in 1978. Saks went on to direct her in several stage productions, including her breakout role as Yente the matchmaker in the original Broadway production of Fiddler on the Roof.

Her biggest Broadway triumph came playing acid-tongued Vera Charles opposite Angela Lansbury in Mame, earning her the 1966 Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Musical.

She’d already made peace with the kind of roles Hollywood saw in her by then, telling one interviewer plainly, “Let’s face it, nobody ever asked me to play Juliet.”

She Waited Seven Years for a Script Good Enough

After Norman Lear’s Maude ended in 1978, Arthur was highly selective about her next project, stepping back into theater rather than chase just any role.

Her one real attempt at a comeback, the 1983 sitcom Amanda’s, an American remake of Fawlty Towers, was canceled quickly.

In 1985, the pilot script for The Golden Girls finally changed her mind. She called the writing “incredibly good, adult and witty,” and the casting of former Maude co-star Rue McClanahan alongside Betty White sealed the decision.

She Left the Second Show Over the Same Frustration

Arthur shocked fans by announcing her departure from The Golden Girls in 1992, ending the show after seven seasons at what she considered its creative peak.

She felt the scripts had grown too surreal, but according to her son and members of the backstage crew, something more personal was also wearing on her.

Jokes about Rose being naive or Blanche being promiscuous were character-driven, but the constant jokes about Dorothy being “manly,” “big,” or “ugly” landed as direct insults to Arthur’s own body and face.

It’s the same core complaint that had driven her away from Maude over a decade earlier, just aimed at her instead of at a script choice.

Her Friendship With Betty White Was Real, and Genuinely Complicated

Arthur, a classically trained stage actress, valued intense focus during rehearsals and tapings.

White, who’d built her career in live television and game shows, loved breaking character to chat with the studio audience between takes, something Arthur found genuinely unprofessional.

White later admitted her own relentless positivity sometimes made things worse. “It was my positive attitude, and that made Bea mad sometimes,” she said. “Sometimes if I was happy, she’d be furious.”

Despite the friction, co-star Rue McClanahan wrote in her memoir that the two women respected each other’s talent completely and knew exactly how to make television magic together.

She Kept Adding to an Already Historic Emmy Record

Arthur won the Primetime Emmy for Outstanding Lead Actress in a Comedy Series twice, once for Maude in 1977 and again for The Golden Girls in 1988.

Across her career she earned nine nominations in that category total, the third-most of any actress in the award’s history, behind only Julia Louis-Dreyfus and Mary Tyler Moore.

In 2002, well after both signature shows had ended, she returned to Broadway one final time with a one-woman show, Bea Arthur on Broadway: Just Between Friends, and the Television Academy inducted her into its Hall of Fame in 2008, the year before she died.

Lung Cancer Ended Her Life in 2009

Bea Arthur died at her home in Los Angeles on April 25, 2009, at age 86. The cause was lung cancer.

She was famously introverted and fiercely private off screen, a real contrast to the loud, commanding women she played for decades, and she never wrote a memoir of her own the way several of her Golden Girls co-stars eventually did. In her will, she left $300,000 to New York’s Ali Forney Center, an organization supporting homeless LGBT youth.

You can read more about the rest of the Golden Girls cast in our full guide to the show, and about the man who gave her her first major role in our piece on Norman Lear.

Bea Arthur, Frequently Asked Questions